Review: Hearts that Survive by Yvonne Lehman

Lydia Beaumont is travelling from London to New York on the Titanic, accompanied by her fiance, John Ancell, and Craven Dowd, an employee of her father - and the man her father wants her to marry. But Lydia is hiding a secret. She is pregnant with John’s child, the result of one night that went too far, despite them both having a Christian faith. Together with her friend, Caroline Chadwick, she plans a historic wedding on the unsinkable ship.

So, less than one chapter in, I had a feeling I could see where this plot was going (well, they are on the Titanic!). I was partly right, and partly wrong. Yes, the ship sank, and John Astor has died three times this week in three different books. But in the end, Hearts That Survivedidn't go anything like how I expected. I was expecting a standard Christian romance story that covered a few months in time or a year at most. Instead I got a much deeper story that covered decades. I admit I overlooked the Amazon product description that used words like ‘epic’ and 'decades later’, indicating a longer timeframe. My excuse is that I didn’t want to come into the book with any preconceived ideas, and I feel justified now I do look at the Amazon listing, because the two aspects of the plot summary occur fifty years apart, which is one of my pet hates as it could be considered a bit of a spoiler…

Lehman has a unique ability to capture the nuances of emotion in her writing, to change her style and tone to reflect the emotions of her characters. This made for difficult reading at times, particularly in the passages after the sinking, when both women were coping with their grief in their own way. The scene inside the ship as she went down was beautifully and sensitively written, with a sad nobility that reminded me of the scene where the Towers come down in Kingsbury's 9/11 novel, One Tuesday Morning. The sinking scenes themselves were confusing, with too many people, too many points of view. But even this gave it a sense of realism, particularly as some scenes showed men and women at their most noble, and others behaving in quite the opposite manner.

After the tragedy, the tone of the writing changes, with subtle differences between Lydia and Caroline's points of view highlighting the differences between them. Frankly, I found the portions from Lydia’s point of view to be depressing. Craven was controlling and manipulative at a time when Lydia did not have the strength to stand up to him, and I didn’t like that, either. So, overall, this was not a novel I particularly enjoyed. The story dragged too much in places, some of the word choices felt out of place, the story changed focus from Lydia to Caroline, and parts of it were confusing with too many characters. But underneath all that, Hearts That Survive has some brilliant writing with some profound spiritual insights, which I appreciated.

For example, at one point, Caroline is thinking that “Out there, she’d seen hundreds and hundreds and hundreds calling on God and Jesus to save them. He didn’t.” This made me think, because it seems so out of character for a Christian novel. I decided Caroline was wrong. God did save them. But we, as humans, often confuse the physical with the eternal. He has promised to save all who believe and call upon Him, just as He has promised us healing. But not all of these promises are fulfilled in this mortal life. God may not have saved the bodies of those crying out to Him, but he did save them, just as He saves those who cry out to Him today.

What do you think?

Thanks to Abingdon Press and NetGalley for providing a free ebook for review.

Review: Echoes of Titanic by Mindy Starns Clark

Echoes of Titanicopens at the 1913 Titanic memorial service, with an unnamed woman thinking of her loss, of the nightmare and of her guilt.  The story then moves to 2012 and to Kelsey Tate, who works for Brennan & Tate, the investment firm established by her great grandmother, Adele Brennan. Kelsey’s PR speech is interrupted by a heckler announcing that Adele perished on the Titanic, and Jocelyn assumed Adele’s identity. While Kelsey discredits the story, it is within the realms of possibility, as the cousins were the same age, and Adele had not seen her father since she was three.  Then Kelsey’s career mentor, Gloria Poole, is found hanged in the company offices hours after the big announcement, an apparent suicide – or is it murder?

Kelsey must resolve the attack on Adele's name and cope with the death of her mentor.  As Kelsey investigates, she begins to questions her own lifestyle and faith. She realises that it was one of many things that changed five years ago when her relationship with Cole fell apart, when Gloria didn’t get an important promotion, and when Kelsey made her first big deal. Kelsey finds things are not as they first appeared and begins to question the actions and motivations of others, as well as her own.

The story flips back and forward between 1912 and 2012, from Adele and Jocelyn to Kelsey as she attempts to solve a century-old mystery within a tight deadline, accompanied by a hint of romance and a hint of suspense and an underlying theme of God's grace and love.

I have read several books by Mindy Starns Clark, but Echoes of Titanicis the first that she has co-authored with her husband, John Campbell Clark, a lifelong Titanic buff, whose background in accounting comes through almost too strongly in some of the investment passages.  Another problem was that there was too much backtracking and repetition of the family history (at least one passage could have been deleted). I suspect that someone thought that an established author like Mindy Starns Clark would not need much editing. That might normally be true, but if so then John Campbell Clark is a first time author who certainly does need some editorial guidance. 

One thing I have noticed about Mindy Starns Clark's heroines is that they have an annoying habit of resorting to physical exercise in times of stress, and Kelsey is no exception. However, this might say more about me than it does about Clark's books...

Thanks to Harvest House and NetGalley for providing a free ebook for review.

Review: By the Light of the Silvery Moon by Tricia Goyer

2012 is the centenary of the sinking of the Titanic, and this week I am reviewing two novels set on the fated ship and a third that has Titanic flashbacks. Hopefully they will be an improvement on the movie! (While I like both Kate Winslett and Leonardo di Caprio as actors, I didn't like the movie plot and haven't listened to Celine Dion since).  The movie will be re-released on 6 April in 3D as a tribute (with the Blu-ray to follow. Cashing in?) As you may have guessed, I won't be going to see it. Anyway, on to By the Light of the Silvery Moon.

Quentin's mother drowned when he was only a small boy, and he is now returning to America. Although he comes from an affluent background, he has been barely surviving on the streets of London for the last two years. Damien Walpole and his father are returning to America after a business trip to London, where they also searched for Damien's lost younger brother. The two brothers are quite different, but both have their strengths, and both have their faults.

Amelia is boarding the Titanic with her Aunt Neda, who has raised her since her mother left to follow the call of the sea when Amelia was just six. The two are now travelling to America at the behest of Elizabeth, Neda's daughter, and her neighbour Mr Chapman, who has been corresponding with Amelia and has paid for their tickets. Amelia has a passion for helping those without fathers or mothers, no doubt because of her own upbringing. A twist of fate and an act of kindness sees Quentin on the same voyage.

The key in a book about a well-known historical event is to engage the reader to the point that they get so engrossed in the story that they forget what is coming. Goyer has achieved this by creating a cast of interrelated characters that the reader is keen to explore, and written with a very readable voice.  The themes are familiar - pride, love, forgiveness and reconciliation.  By the Light of the Silvery Moonis quite plainly a Christian novel, with Christian characters and an underlying Christian theme, but it only rarely sermonises.

If there are any faults, they would be that Amelia is almost too good to be true - I got somewhat tired of reading about her never-ending good deeds.  Another potential fault is that the plot has overtones of the biblical story of the Prodigal Son, but with two added twists: which brother survives? Which brother gets the girl?  It's not that I don't like the story of the Prodigal Son - I do - it is just that I prefer original stories where I am not distracted by thinking I know what is going to happen (if that makes sense, given that I am reading a novel where I know the ship sinks and over 1,500 people drown). But Goyer manages to conquer even this potential fault, by providing insight into the feelings and motivations of the responsible brother. He often comes across as proud and unlikeable in sermons, but Goyer makes him likeable and heroic.

There were a few things that annoyed me about this book, mostly to do with the editing and fact checking, which will hopefully be cleared up in the final print edition. But the writing, the plot, the themes, the characters, the integration of a clear and uncompromising gospel message - those things were excellent. The prodigal son and his responsible brother facing the icy waters surrounding the Titanic raise the question of another inheritance, a spiritual inheritance, an inheritance that we can forget but that can never be destroyed.

Thanks to Barbour Publishing and NetGalley for providing a free ebook for review.

Review: Gone to Ground by Brandilyn Collins

The Closet Killings have claimed five victims in three years in the town of Amaryllis (pop. 1700). All middle-aged women who lived alone. All killed in their beds, then stuffed in the bedroom closet. Now there is a sixth victim… young widow Erika Hollinger.

Gone to Ground is told from three different points of view, three women who are sure they know who the murderer is, and who have reason to want to hide that knowledge.  Cleaner Cherrie Mae Devine knows the murderer is the mayor.  Pregnant Tully Phillips knows it is her husband. And hairdresser Deena Ruckland knows it is her simple-minded younger brother.  Who is right? Or are these simply red herrings, designed to distract us from the real murderer?  The story is interspersed with articles from local Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist Trent Williams, and these give background information about the town and the personalities involved in the investigation.

This is an excellent who-dun-it, with plenty of twists and turns to keep the investigators (and the reader) guessing.  The three narrators were well-developed characters, with each woman having her own distinct voice, which makes it easy to understand the changing points of view.  I liked each of them (although Cherrie Mae’s use of the word ‘police’ got old quickly – if the emphasis had to be included, I think I would have found ‘po-lice’ less intrusive).

While Cherrie Mae is a Christian and she prays with the other narrators, it is not clear whether or not they are Christians, nor is it relevant. Although Gone to Ground is not an overtly Christian novel, this is less of an issue to me in a mystery or thriller than it would being a romance, where it is vital that the hero and heroine share a relationship with God. Overall, Gone to Ground is well worth reading if you like mysteries.  Recommended.

Thanks to B&H Publishing and NetGalley for providing a free ebook for review.

Review: Saving Hope by Margaret Daley

Saving Hope is not a story for the faint-hearted. Kate Winslow runs Beacon of Hope, a shelter for teenage runaways, all of whom are ex-prostitutes. She is particularly attached to Rose, but Rose is missing.  Wyatt Sheridan is a Texas Ranger who works on a task force fighting child prostitution. He is also the father of fourteen-year-old Maddie.  Wyatt and Kate are drawn together when a dead teenaged girl is found near an abandoned white van that is registered to Beacon of Hope.  Wyatt and Kate work together to find Rose before more girls go missing - or are found murdered.  Meanwhile, Kate's funding is cut and they must fight a powerful enemy who seems to know more than they could.

As the story progresses, we meet a mysterious man known as King, who is behind the prostitution ring, and who will no doubt attempt to abduct Maddie. The tension builds as we try to work out who King might be...  It is also apparent early on that King is getting inside information about the investigation, but it is unclear who is the source, giving the reader another mystery to ponder.  But is King the kingpin in the illegal operation? Or is someone else pulling the strings? 

At one point I thought I had identified King, but then that didn't fit. I was gratified to find at the end that some of my theories were correct, even if others were not, and it had the added bonus of a growing romance between Kate and Wyatt. The characters, particularly Kate, pray and speak of attending church, but this is not obtrusive nor does it feel 'preachy', which satisfied my desire for some Christian content in Christian fiction.

Overall, Saving Hopewas a sound romantic suspense novel that touched on some difficult issues in modern society.  I know that many readers of Christian fiction prefer to avoid potentially disturbing issues such as these even though the difficult issues were addressed with a high degree of sensitivity, and no graphic language or imagery.  Saving Hope was an engaging read that I anticipate will be enjoyed by fans of the genre.    I would certainly read more books from Margaret Daley.

Thanks to Abingdon Press and NetGalley for providing a free ebook for review.